TCS Daily

Giving Thanks for Turkey

By Ariel Cohen - November 25, 2003 12:00 AM

As the ruins of the British Consulate and HSBC Bank in Istanbul were still smoldering, and the victims of an earlier bombing of two synagogues were buried, Turkey braced for more homicide bombings.


The November 20 attacks, which killed 30, came days after bombings at two Istanbul synagogues killed 23 more. Over 500 people were wounded.  An Al Qaeda-linked Turkish terror cell, the Islamic Great Eastern Raiders' Front, has admitted guilt for the deadly attacks. More than 1,000 Turkish volunteers are believed to have fought and trained in Afghanistan, Bosnia and Chechnya. Turkey's reluctance to send troops to Iraq did not prevent carnage on its soil.


On the day of the attack, Turkish Foreign Minister Abdallah Gul said on CNN that his country would not be deterred by bloodshed. "Turkey will certainly not bow to terror," he said. "We hope this is the beginning of a new era in fighting terrorism globally." Turkish officials and commentators vouched that the war on terrorism will escalate.


Turkey's geopolitical position, straddling Europe and the Middle East, its maritime and pipeline transit routes, connecting Iraq, the Caspian, the Black Sea and the Mediterranean. its democracy and religious tolerance, all make it a key U.S. ally in the region.


As a result of the attacks, Turkey is likely to tilt over towards the U.S.-led anti-terror coalition. The Turkish government is certain to improve the capabilities of the country's security forces to fight Islamist mega-terrorism. That calls for intelligence sharing and cooperation with the US, UK and Israel.


Some in the Turkish military and security establishment are suspicious of the EU's reluctance to take tough measures against Al Qaeda and its networks. However, attempts to join the European Union (EU) will continue.

Turkey is not turning into an Iranian-style religious dictatorship. However, the elites will face a choice between more democracy and striving towards EU membership, on the one hand, and a robust pursuit of terrorists, sometimes beyond the EU's stringent human rights standards, one the other.


The 'Muslim democrats' of the ruling AK Party will inevitably be forced to fight Islamist terror. There are two major wings of the AKP: the liberals -- who seem to dominate the party's decision-making mechanism -- and the conservatives. The latter are led by Bülent Arinç, whose group has until now supported more radical positions when it came to divisive religious issues like wearing head scarves, and relaxed guidelines for religious education. AK religious radicals do not practice violence but are sympathetic to it. As Professor Ahmet K. Han of Istanbul Bilgi University said, "these radicals are creating intolerable legitimacy for terrorism." 


In the aftermath of the terrorist bombings, the Turkish military, along with its traditional decision making elites, the "deep state" -- security services and state bureaucracy, the anti-EU groups, the hard-line support of Prime Minister Rauf Denktash of Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus -- are all likely to place increased political pressure on the AKP to change its reformist policies. The level of pressure on the ruling party is also likely to be exacerbated by the economic ripple effect of terrorist attacks.

The recent terror attacks will have negative economic consequences on the brittle Turkish economy, which was barely recovering after a painful recession. Phillip Rosenblatt, a U.S. attorney practicing in Istanbul says  that the attacks of the past weeks came at a time when the economic stresses had just begun easing up. "With little fanfare, the current Government had put wide ranging reforms in place to align Turkey's economic, social and political legislation with those in the European Community. Turkey hopes to receive a date from the EU at the end of next year to commence negotiations on full membership. Tourism to Turkey, which is $15 billion out of a total GDP of $200 billion, is almost certainly going to be hurt, especially if there are follow-up attacks on tourist targets along the Mediterranean coast."


The Bush Administration should welcome Turkey's firm commitment to fight terrorism and oppose its state sponsors. It should expand security and intelligence cooperation with the Turkish military and security services, initiating joint operations to penetrate Al Qaeda and other radical Islamist terrorist organizations.


Turkish and U.S. security agencies should jointly conduct an audit of potential terror targets, especially on and around the Bosphorus Straits and Incirlik US air base.


Finally, the U.S. should support Turkish economic, legal, and democratic reforms aimed at joining the EU, including declaring a date certain for Turkish accession to the EU by the end of 2004.


Turkey is reeling in the aftermath of what many in Ankara have called "our 9/11." These acts of mayhem come after similar attacks in Iraq, Morocco, Tunis, and Saudi Arabia and are aimed at destabilizing these Muslim states The attacks are likely to change Turkish society, state policies and politics, as much, if not more, than the September 11th terrorism changed America. 


After the slaughter, Turkey is more likely to focus on domestic issues and become less involved in the Caucasus and Central Asia, where its profile has already declined in the recent years. Moreover, Turkey will be more concerned about the security of the Bosphorus Straits, a relatively easy target for a terrorist maritime mega-attack, possibly involving oil or liquid natural gas (LNG) tankers or the two bridges spanning the Straits.


The fallout from the latest series of terrorist atrocities for this important Eurasian country, for the Middle East, and for the war on terror, is just beginning to be felt.


Ariel Cohen, Ph.D., is Research Fellow at the Heritage Foundation. His last visit to Turkey was in June 2003.


TCS Daily Archives